web3privacy
/
explorer
mirror of https://github.com/web3privacy/explorer.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
explorer/Web3privacynowplatform/scoringmodel/DeFi category prototype.md

396 lines
38 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

# Scoring model testing repo
_Here we test the latest scoring approach for non-techies (30 Oct, 2023) whenever service is private or not._
[Applied scoring approach](https://mirror.xyz/0x0f1F3DAf416B74DB3DE55Eb4D7513a80F4841073/E9QPx9iKgPXPqEsAN-YklipSRJy9VTBMOLwwEcqqVpU)
**Simplified overview**
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| **Test project** | available & active GitHub / not (25%) | Live or 🚧 (exclusion criteria) | public team / not (25%) | available & not marketing docs / not (25%) | available & up to date third-party audit / not (25%) | total |
| -> | 25% | 🚧 | 25% | 25% | 25% | from 0% to 100% |
**Note**:
- persona: non-techie
- max score: 100% (public GitHub, third-party audit, public Docs, public team)
- min score: 0%
- 🚩 - represents project sunset, empty or inactive Github, marketing docs
- 🚧 - represents that the project is not live on mainnet, this is an exclusion criteria that forces project score to be 0%
## DeFi
![alt text](https://github.com/Msiusko/web3privacy/blob/main/static-assets/DEFI.png?raw=true)
**Total**: 38 projects
| Project | Description | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- | ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Firn Protocol](https://app.firn.cash) | Firn is the first-ever zero-knowledge privacy platform in the _account-based_ model, and introduces pluggable, flexible privacy to Ethereum-based chains. ✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/firnprotocol)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.firn.cash) | [BlockSec](https://github.com/blocksecteam/audit-reports/blob/main/solidity/blocksec_firnprotocol_v1.0-signed.pdf) | 75% |
| [Shade](https://shadeprotocol.io) | Shade Protocol is an array of connected privacy-preserving DeFi applications built on Secret Network | ([GitHub](https://github.com/securesecrets/shade)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/) | 🚩 2022: [2 audits](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/research/audit-log) | 75% |
| [Silent protocol](https://www.silentprotocol.org) | Silent Protocol is the first protocol enabling compliant full-stack privacy for smart contract assets and web3 applications at scale. | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [XATA](https://www.xata.fi) | A MEV Minimization solution to survive the Dark Forest | - | 🚩 | anon | ([Docs](https://docs.xata.fi)) | - | 25% |
| [Sienna Network](https://sienna.network) | Sienna is a privacy-first and cross-chain decentralized finance platform where you can privately swap, lend and convert your tokens into their private equivalent | 🚩`LOW` ([GitHub](https://github.com/SiennaNetwork)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.sienna.network/main/) | 🚩 2022: [9 audits](https://sienna.network/audits/) | 75% |
| [Elusiv](https://elusiv.io) | Create blockchain privacy solutions that are built for everyday transactions — with the power of scalable ZK infrastructure on Solana ✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/elusiv-privacy)) | live | ([Public](https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompany=%5B%2280778213%22%5D&origin=COMPANY_PAGE_CANNED_SEARCH&sid=s_%40)) | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.elusiv.io/) | - | 75% |
| [Offshift](https://www.offshift.io) | Offshift’s proprietary Shifting mechanism allows users to Shift between our native token, XFT, and a full palette of private synthetics | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitLab](https://open.offshift.io/offshiftXFT)) | live | ([anon](https://offshift.io/#team)) | - | - | 25% |
| [CAPE](https://www.espressosys.com/product) | Configurable Asset Privacy for Ethereum | ([GitHub](https://github.com/EspressoSystems/cape)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.espressosys.com/sequencer/espresso-sequencer-architecture/readme) | - | 50% |
| [Evanesco](https://evanesco.org) | A financial protocol platform that combines Layer0 network infrastructure with a private computing framework. | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Evanesco-Labs)) | live | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [Dusk Network](https://dusk.network) | Is technology for securities. An open source and secure blockchain (DLT) infrastructure that businesses use to tokenize financial instruments and automate costly processes. | ([GitHub](https://github.com/dusk-network)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://dusk.network/pages/team)) | - | - | 50% |
| [Manta Pay](https://app.manta.network/dolphin/transact) | MantaPay is coming to Calamari as the first privacy payment solution in the Kusama ecosystem.✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Manta-Network)) | testnet v3 | public | [Docs](https://docs.manta.network/docs/Introduction) | - | 75% |
| [Webb](https://app.webb.tools/#/tornado) | an interoperable private bridge ✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/webb-tools)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.webb.tools/docs/) | [Audit of the DKG-Substrate pallet](https://blog.webb.tools/webbs-evm-bridge-security-audit-completed-by-veridise/) | 75% |
| [Panther Protocol](https://www.pantherprotocol.io) | is a decentralized privacy metaprotocol enabling confidential, trusted transactions and interoperability with DeFi ✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/pantherprotocol)) | live | ([Public](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/)) | [Docs](https://docs.pantherprotocol.io/docs/start-here/panther-protocol-documentation) | 🚩 2021: [ZKP Vesting](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Vesting.pdf), [ZKP Token](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Token.pdf) | 100% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [zk.money](https://zk.money) | The private DeFi yield aggregator for Ethereum.✨️**ZK** | ([Docs](https://docs.aztec.network/zk-money/userguide)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.aztec.network) | - | 25% |
| [RAILGUN](https://railgun.org) | Private transfers and DeFi infra for Ethereum, Polygon, Binance Smart Chain and Arbitrum.✨️**ZK** | [Github](https://github.com/Railgun-Community) | live | ([Public](https://railgun.org/#/contributors)) | [Docs](https://docs.railgun.org/developer-guide/cookbook/cookbook-overview) | [5 audits](https://assets.railgun.org/docs/audits/) | 100% |
| [Umbra](https://app.umbra.cash) | As a protocol, Umbra defines a simple set of standards, coupled with a singleton smart contract instance, to enable stealth addresses on Ethereum | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ScopeLift/umbra-protocol)) | live | anon | - | 🚩 2021: [3 audits](https://app.umbra.cash/faq#security) | 50% |
| [Light Shield](https://shield.lightprotocol.com) | private transactions for Solana. | - | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | 🚩 2022: [Code review](https://github.com/Lightprotocol/light-protocol-v1/blob/main/Audit/Light%20Protocol%20Audit%20Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Horizon](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | Decentralized Anonymous Payment Systems ✨️**ZK** | - | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | [Messier](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/messier) | 50% |
| [Diva](https://www.diva.exchange/en/) | Free banking technology for everyone: everyone can join in, everyone can use DIVA.EXCHANGE | ([GitHub](https://github.com/diva-exchange)) | 🚧 | - | ([Public](https://www.diva.exchange/en/team-and-contact/)) | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | - | - | 75% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Yellow Submarine](https://ys.finance) | the first and only multichain dApp to offer plug-and-play private DeFi (PriFi) across all EVM-compatible chains | ([Docs](https://yellow-s.gitbook.io/docs/ys-basics/introduction)) | 🚩 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [BasicSwap](https://basicswapdex.com) | Private Cross-Chain DEX | ([GitHub](https://github.com/tecnovert/basicswap/blob/master/doc/install.md)) | live | ([anon](https://particl.io/)) | - | - | 50% |
| [Common](https://common.fi) | Common will be a decentralized exchange that mitigates the Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) problem. | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Sacred](https://sacred.finance) | multi-chain DeFi Platform offers private Yield Bearing Deposits to DeFi users ✨️**ZK* | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Sacred-Finance)) | 🚧 | Ethereum, Polygon | anon | - | - | 25% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Sahara](https://sahara.network) | The first dedicated privacy protocol ecosystem that enables on-platform trade between volatile and stable assets | - | 🚩 | ([Public](https://sahara.network/)) | - | 🚩 2022: [Vesting contract](https://sahara.network/resources/sahara-security-audit.pdf) | 50% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [DeFiner](https://definer.org) | Permission-less and configurable decentralized lending protocol with privacy 100% protected ✨️**ZK** | ([GitHub](https://github.com/DeFinerOrg)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.definer.org) | 🚩 2020: [Savings audits](https://docs.definer.org/v/copy-of-definer.org/security/audits) | 75% |
| [Hurricane Protocol](https://hurricane.money) | A fully decentralized protocol offering private transactions on both the Terra & NEAR | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Hurricane-Protocol)) | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.hurricane.money) | - | 50% |
| [StealthPay](https://www.stealthpay.cash) | a stealth address protocol for Ethereum.| 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/cryptoadong)) | 🚩 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [BlackBox](https://blackbox.cash) | collection of tools allowing you send & receive SCRT anonymously | ([GitHub](https://github.com/TriviumNode)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [Hinkal](https://hinkal.pro) | an easy-to-integrate privacy SDK that helps users anonymize transactions. | - | live | ([Public](https://hinkal.pro/#section-team)) | - | [Competitive security](https://github.com/Secure3Audit/Secure3Academy/blob/main/audit_reports/Hinkal/Hinkal_final_Secure3_Audit_Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Conceal Network](https://conceal.network) | privacy-protected DeFi & encrypted comms | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ConcealNetwork)) | live | ([anon](https://conceal.network/team/)) | [Docs](https://conceal.network/wiki/doku.php) | - | 50% |
| [CIA protocol](https://ciaprotocol.com) | Building the truest form of DeFi with privacy by default. | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [CoinBook](https://www.coinbook.app) | Decentralized Multi Chain P2P Order Book | - | 🚩 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Seven Seas](https://www.sevenseas.exchange) | No KYC, privacy Focused crypto Exchange | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | 0% |
| [NonKYC](https://nonkyc.io) | NonKYC Exchange | - | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | 0% |
| [zkUSD](https://zkusd.money/#Features) | Privacy-Preserving Collateralized Lending & more | 🚩 | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/zkUSDLabs)) | - | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://zkusd.gitbook.io/zkusd-documentation) | - | 50% |
| [Spiral Finance](https://www.spiralfi.io) | non-custodial privacy solution based on ZK-Sync ERA ✨️**ZK** | - | 🚧 | - | ([Docs](https://docs.spiralfi.io/introduction/spiral-finance)) | - | 25% |
| [Fairy](https://fairyswap.finance/swap) | comprehensive DeFi platform for token swaps, lending, NFT trading, collateralization | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Fairyswap)) | 🚩 | - | [Docs](https://fairy-swap.gitbook.io/fairyswap-v2/getting-started/about-fairyswap-v2) | 🚩 2022: [Certik](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/fairyswap) | 75% |
| [Shade Cash](https://shade.cash) | A decentralized protocol for private transactions on Fantom Opera | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/ShadeCash)) | 🚩 | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://shadecash.gitbook.io/shadecash) | - | 50% |
# Post-assesment breakdown
## 100% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Panther Protocol](https://www.pantherprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/pantherprotocol)) | live | ([Public](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/)) | [Docs](https://docs.pantherprotocol.io/docs/start-here/panther-protocol-documentation) | 🚩 2021: [ZKP Vesting](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Vesting.pdf), [ZKP Token](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Token.pdf) | 100% |
| [RAILGUN](https://railgun.org) | [Github](https://github.com/Railgun-Community) | live | ([Public](https://railgun.org/#/contributors)) | [Docs](https://docs.railgun.org/developer-guide/cookbook/cookbook-overview) | [5 audits](https://assets.railgun.org/docs/audits/) | 100% |
**total**: 2 projects
**Details**:
- 1 red flag 🚩
## 75% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Firn Protocol](https://app.firn.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/firnprotocol)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.firn.cash) | [BlockSec](https://github.com/blocksecteam/audit-reports/blob/main/solidity/blocksec_firnprotocol_v1.0-signed.pdf) | 75% |
| [Shade](https://shadeprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/securesecrets/shade)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/) | 🚩 2022: [2 audits](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/research/audit-log) | 75% |
| [Sienna Network](https://sienna.network) | 🚩`LOW` ([GitHub](https://github.com/SiennaNetwork)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.sienna.network/main/) | 🚩 2022: [9 audits](https://sienna.network/audits/) | 75% |
| [Elusiv](https://elusiv.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/elusiv-privacy)) | live | ([Public](https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompany=%5B%2280778213%22%5D&origin=COMPANY_PAGE_CANNED_SEARCH&sid=s_%40)) | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.elusiv.io/) | - | 75% |
| [Manta Pay](https://app.manta.network/dolphin/transact) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Manta-Network)) | 🚧 | public | [Docs](https://docs.manta.network/docs/Introduction) | - | 75% |
| [Webb](https://app.webb.tools/#/tornado) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/webb-tools)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.webb.tools/docs/) | [Audit of the DKG-Substrate pallet](https://blog.webb.tools/webbs-evm-bridge-security-audit-completed-by-veridise/) | 75% |
| [Diva](https://www.diva.exchange/en/) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/diva-exchange)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://www.diva.exchange/en/team-and-contact/)) | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | - | - | 75% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [DeFiner](https://definer.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/DeFinerOrg)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.definer.org) | 🚩 2020: [Savings audits](https://docs.definer.org/v/copy-of-definer.org/security/audits) | 75% |
| [Fairy](https://fairyswap.finance/swap) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Fairyswap)) | 🚩 | - | [Docs](https://fairy-swap.gitbook.io/fairyswap-v2/getting-started/about-fairyswap-v2) | 🚩 2022: [Certik](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/fairyswap) | 75% |
**total**: 9 projects
**Details**:
- 7 red flags 🚩
- 1 sunset
## 50% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [CAPE](https://www.espressosys.com/product) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/EspressoSystems/cape)) | testnet | anon | [Docs](https://docs.espressosys.com/sequencer/espresso-sequencer-architecture/readme) | - | 50% |
| [Dusk Network](https://dusk.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/dusk-network)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://dusk.network/pages/team)) | - | - | 50% |
| [Umbra](https://app.umbra.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ScopeLift/umbra-protocol)) | live | anon | - | 🚩 2021: [3 audits](https://app.umbra.cash/faq#security) | 50% |
| [Light Shield](https://shield.lightprotocol.com) | - | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | 🚩 2022: [Code review](https://github.com/Lightprotocol/light-protocol-v1/blob/main/Audit/Light%20Protocol%20Audit%20Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Horizon](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | - | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | [Messier](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/messier) | 50% |
| [BasicSwap](https://basicswapdex.com) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/tecnovert/basicswap/blob/master/doc/install.md)) | live | ([anon](https://particl.io/)) | - | - | 50% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Sahara](https://sahara.network) | - | 🚩 | ([Public](https://sahara.network/)) | - | 🚩 2022: [Vesting contract](https://sahara.network/resources/sahara-security-audit.pdf) | 50% |
| [Hurricane Protocol](https://hurricane.money) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Hurricane-Protocol)) | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.hurricane.money) | - | 50% |
| [Hinkal](https://hinkal.pro) | - | live | ([Public](https://hinkal.pro/#section-team)) | - | [Competitive security](https://github.com/Secure3Audit/Secure3Academy/blob/main/audit_reports/Hinkal/Hinkal_final_Secure3_Audit_Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Conceal Network](https://conceal.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ConcealNetwork)) | live | ([anon](https://conceal.network/team/)) | [Docs](https://conceal.network/wiki/doku.php) | - | 50% |
| [zkUSD](https://zkusd.money/#Features) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/zkUSDLabs)) | 🚧 | - | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://zkusd.gitbook.io/zkusd-documentation) | - | 50% |
| [Shade Cash](https://shade.cash) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/ShadeCash)) | 🚧 | - | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://shadecash.gitbook.io/shadecash) | - | 50% |
**total**: 12 projects
**Details**:
- 11 red flags 🚩
- 1 sunset
## 25% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| 🚩 **sunset** [XATA](https://www.xata.fi) | - | 🚩 | anon | ([Docs](https://docs.xata.fi)) | - | 25% |
| [Offshift](https://www.offshift.io) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitLab](https://open.offshift.io/offshiftXFT)) | live | ([anon](https://offshift.io/#team)) | - | - | 25% |
| [Evanesco](https://evanesco.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Evanesco-Labs)) | live | anon | - | - | 25% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [zk.money](https://zk.money) | ([Docs](https://docs.aztec.network/zk-money/userguide)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.aztec.network) | - | 25% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Yellow Submarine](https://ys.finance) | ([Docs](https://yellow-s.gitbook.io/docs/ys-basics/introduction)) | 🚩 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [Sacred](https://sacred.finance) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Sacred-Finance)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [StealthPay](https://www.stealthpay.cash) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/cryptoadong)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [BlackBox](https://blackbox.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/TriviumNode)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [Spiral Finance](https://www.spiralfi.io) | - | 🚧 | - | ([Docs](https://docs.spiralfi.io/introduction/spiral-finance)) | - | 25% |
**total**: 9 projects
**Details**:
- 6 red flags 🚩
- 3 sunsets
## 0% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Silent protocol](https://www.silentprotocol.org) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Common](https://common.fi) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [CIA protocol](https://ciaprotocol.com) | - | 🚧 | Ethereum | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [CoinBook](https://www.coinbook.app) | - | 🚩 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Seven Seas](https://www.sevenseas.exchange) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | - | 0% |
| [NonKYC](https://nonkyc.io) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | - | 0% |
**total**: 6 projects
**Details**:
- 1 red flag 🚩
- 1 sunset
# Red-flag applicable breakdown
**Note**:
- 🚩 - represents - 25% of scoring
- sunset - decreases scoring to 0%
## 100% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [RAILGUN](https://railgun.org) | [Github](https://github.com/Railgun-Community) | live | ([Public](https://railgun.org/#/contributors)) | [Docs](https://docs.railgun.org/developer-guide/cookbook/cookbook-overview) | [5 audits](https://assets.railgun.org/docs/audits/) | 100% |
**total**: 1 project
## 75% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Firn Protocol](https://app.firn.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/firnprotocol)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.firn.cash) | [BlockSec](https://github.com/blocksecteam/audit-reports/blob/main/solidity/blocksec_firnprotocol_v1.0-signed.pdf) | 75% |
| [Manta Pay](https://app.manta.network/dolphin/transact) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Manta-Network)) | 🚧 | public | [Docs](https://docs.manta.network/docs/Introduction) | - | 75% |
| [Webb](https://app.webb.tools/#/tornado) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/webb-tools)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.webb.tools/docs/) | [Audit of the DKG-Substrate pallet](https://blog.webb.tools/webbs-evm-bridge-security-audit-completed-by-veridise/) | 75% |
| [Diva](https://www.diva.exchange/en/) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/diva-exchange)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://www.diva.exchange/en/team-and-contact/)) | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | - | - | 75% |
| [Panther Protocol](https://www.pantherprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/pantherprotocol)) | live | ([Public](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/)) | [Docs](https://docs.pantherprotocol.io/docs/start-here/panther-protocol-documentation) | 🚩 2021: [ZKP Vesting](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Vesting.pdf), [ZKP Token](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Token.pdf) | 75% |
**total**: 5 projects
**Details**:
- 1 red flag 🚩
## 50% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [CAPE](https://www.espressosys.com/product) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/EspressoSystems/cape)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.espressosys.com/sequencer/espresso-sequencer-architecture/readme) | - | 50% |
| [Dusk Network](https://dusk.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/dusk-network)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://dusk.network/pages/team)) | - | - | 50% |
| [BasicSwap](https://basicswapdex.com) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/tecnovert/basicswap/blob/master/doc/install.md)) | 🚧 | ([anon](https://particl.io/)) | - | - | 50% |
| [Hinkal](https://hinkal.pro) | - | live | ([Public](https://hinkal.pro/#section-team)) | - | [Competitive security](https://github.com/Secure3Audit/Secure3Academy/blob/main/audit_reports/Hinkal/Hinkal_final_Secure3_Audit_Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Conceal Network](https://conceal.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ConcealNetwork)) | live | ([anon](https://conceal.network/team/)) | [Docs](https://conceal.network/wiki/doku.php) | - | 50% |
| [Elusiv](https://elusiv.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/elusiv-privacy)) | live | ([Public](https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompany=%5B%2280778213%22%5D&origin=COMPANY_PAGE_CANNED_SEARCH&sid=s_%40)) | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.elusiv.io/) | - | 50% |
| [Fairy](https://fairyswap.finance/swap) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Fairyswap)) | 🚩 | - | [Docs](https://fairy-swap.gitbook.io/fairyswap-v2/getting-started/about-fairyswap-v2) | 🚩 2022: [Certik](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/fairyswap) | 50% |
| [Shade](https://shadeprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/securesecrets/shade)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/) | 🚩 2022: [2 audits](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/research/audit-log) | 50% |
**total**: 8 projects
**Details**:
- 3 red flags 🚩
## 25% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Evanesco](https://evanesco.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Evanesco-Labs)) | live | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [BlackBox](https://blackbox.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/TriviumNode)) | 🚧 | anon | - | 25% |
| [Spiral Finance](https://www.spiralfi.io) | - | 🚧 | - | ([Docs](https://docs.spiralfi.io/introduction/spiral-finance)) | - | 25% |
| [Horizon](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | - | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | [Messier](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/messier) | 25% |
| [Umbra](https://app.umbra.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ScopeLift/umbra-protocol)) | live | anon | - | 🚩 2021: [3 audits](https://app.umbra.cash/faq#security) | 25% |
| [Light Shield](https://shield.lightprotocol.com) | - | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | 🚩 2022: [Code review](https://github.com/Lightprotocol/light-protocol-v1/blob/main/Audit/Light%20Protocol%20Audit%20Report.pdf) | 25% |
| [Sienna Network](https://sienna.network) | 🚩`LOW` ([GitHub](https://github.com/SiennaNetwork)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.sienna.network/main/) | 🚩 2022: [9 audits](https://sienna.network/audits/) | 25% |
**total**: 7 projects
**Details**:
- 5 red flags 🚩
## 0% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Silent protocol](https://www.silentprotocol.org) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Common](https://common.fi) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [CIA protocol](https://ciaprotocol.com) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [CoinBook](https://www.coinbook.app) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Seven Seas](https://www.sevenseas.exchange) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | 0% |
| [NonKYC](https://nonkyc.io) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [zk.money](https://zk.money) | ([Docs](https://docs.aztec.network/zk-money/userguide)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.aztec.network) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Yellow Submarine](https://ys.finance) | ([Docs](https://yellow-s.gitbook.io/docs/ys-basics/introduction)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Sacred](https://sacred.finance) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Sacred-Finance)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [StealthPay](https://www.stealthpay.cash) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/cryptoadong)) | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [XATA](https://www.xata.fi) | - | 🚩 | anon | ([Docs](https://docs.xata.fi)) | - | 0% |
| [Offshift](https://www.offshift.io) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitLab](https://open.offshift.io/offshiftXFT)) | live | ([anon](https://offshift.io/#team)) | - | - | 0% |
| [zkUSD](https://zkusd.money/#Features) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/zkUSDLabs)) | 🚧 | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://zkusd.gitbook.io/zkusd-documentation) | - | 0% |
| [Shade Cash](https://shade.cash) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/ShadeCash)) | 🚧 | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://shadecash.gitbook.io/shadecash) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Sahara](https://sahara.network) | - | 🚩 | ([Public](https://sahara.network/)) | - | 🚩 2022: [Vesting contract](https://sahara.network/resources/sahara-security-audit.pdf) | 0% |
| [Hurricane Protocol](https://hurricane.money) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Hurricane-Protocol)) | 🚩 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.hurricane.money) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [DeFiner](https://definer.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/DeFinerOrg)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.definer.org) | 🚩 2020: [Savings audits](https://docs.definer.org/v/copy-of-definer.org/security/audits) | 75% |
**total**: 17 projects
**Details**:
- 17 red flags 🚩
- 6 sunsets
# 🚧-flag applicable breakdown (exclusion criteria)
**Note**:
- 🚧 - represents that the project is not live on mainnet, this is an exclusion criteria that forces project score to be 0%
## 100% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [RAILGUN](https://railgun.org) | [Github](https://github.com/Railgun-Community) | live | ([Public](https://railgun.org/#/contributors)) | [Docs](https://docs.railgun.org/developer-guide/cookbook/cookbook-overview) | [5 audits](https://assets.railgun.org/docs/audits/) | 100% |
**total**: 1 project
## 75% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Firn Protocol](https://app.firn.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/firnprotocol)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.firn.cash) | [BlockSec](https://github.com/blocksecteam/audit-reports/blob/main/solidity/blocksec_firnprotocol_v1.0-signed.pdf) | 75% |
**total**: 1 projects
**Details**:
- 1 red flag 🚩
## 50% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Hinkal](https://hinkal.pro) | - | live | ([Public](https://hinkal.pro/#section-team)) | - | [Competitive security](https://github.com/Secure3Audit/Secure3Academy/blob/main/audit_reports/Hinkal/Hinkal_final_Secure3_Audit_Report.pdf) | 50% |
| [Conceal Network](https://conceal.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ConcealNetwork)) | live | ([anon](https://conceal.network/team/)) | [Docs](https://conceal.network/wiki/doku.php) | - | 50% |
| [Elusiv](https://elusiv.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/elusiv-privacy)) | live | ([Public](https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompany=%5B%2280778213%22%5D&origin=COMPANY_PAGE_CANNED_SEARCH&sid=s_%40)) | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.elusiv.io/) | - | 50% |
| [Fairy](https://fairyswap.finance/swap) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Fairyswap)) | 🚩 | - | [Docs](https://fairy-swap.gitbook.io/fairyswap-v2/getting-started/about-fairyswap-v2) | 🚩 2022: [Certik](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/fairyswap) | 50% |
| [Shade](https://shadeprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/securesecrets/shade)) | live | anon | [Docs](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/) | 🚩 2022: [2 audits](https://docs.shadeprotocol.io/shade-protocol/research/audit-log) | 50% |
**total**: 5 projects
**Details**:
- 5 red flags 🚩
## 25% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Evanesco](https://evanesco.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Evanesco-Labs)) | live | anon | - | - | 25% |
| [Umbra](https://app.umbra.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/ScopeLift/umbra-protocol)) | live | anon | - | 🚩 2021: [3 audits](https://app.umbra.cash/faq#security) | 25% |
| [Light Shield](https://shield.lightprotocol.com) | - | mlive | anon | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | 🚩 2022: [Code review](https://github.com/Lightprotocol/light-protocol-v1/blob/main/Audit/Light%20Protocol%20Audit%20Report.pdf) | 25% |
**total**: 3 projects
**Details**:
- 2 red flags 🚩
## 0% scoring
| Project | GitHub | Product-readiness | Team | Docs | Audit | Score |
| ------------- |------------- |------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| [Manta Pay](https://app.manta.network/dolphin/transact) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/Manta-Network)) | 🚧 | public | [Docs](https://docs.manta.network/docs/Introduction) | - | 0% |
| [Webb](https://app.webb.tools/#/tornado) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/webb-tools)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.webb.tools/docs/) | [Audit of the DKG-Substrate pallet](https://blog.webb.tools/webbs-evm-bridge-security-audit-completed-by-veridise/) | 0% |
| [Diva](https://www.diva.exchange/en/) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/diva-exchange)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://www.diva.exchange/en/team-and-contact/)) | [Docs](https://docs.lightprotocol.com) | - | - | 0% |
| [CAPE](https://www.espressosys.com/product) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/EspressoSystems/cape)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.espressosys.com/sequencer/espresso-sequencer-architecture/readme) | - | 0% |
| [Dusk Network](https://dusk.network) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/dusk-network)) | 🚧 | ([Public](https://dusk.network/pages/team)) | - | - | 0% |
| [BasicSwap](https://basicswapdex.com) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/tecnovert/basicswap/blob/master/doc/install.md)) | 🚧 | ([anon](https://particl.io/)) | - | - | 0% |
| [BlackBox](https://blackbox.cash) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/TriviumNode)) | 🚧 | anon | - | 0% |
| [Spiral Finance](https://www.spiralfi.io) | - | 🚧 | - | ([Docs](https://docs.spiralfi.io/introduction/spiral-finance)) | - | 0% |
| [Horizon](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | - | 🚧 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://messier.gitbook.io/catalogue-de-messier/messier-applications/horizon) | [Messier](https://skynet.certik.com/projects/messier) | 0% |
| [Sienna Network](https://sienna.network) | 🚩`LOW` ([GitHub](https://github.com/SiennaNetwork)) | 🚧 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.sienna.network/main/) | 🚩 2022: [9 audits](https://sienna.network/audits/) | 0% |
| [Silent protocol](https://www.silentprotocol.org) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Common](https://common.fi) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [CIA protocol](https://ciaprotocol.com) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [CoinBook](https://www.coinbook.app) | - | 🚧 | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Seven Seas](https://www.sevenseas.exchange) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | 0% |
| [NonKYC](https://nonkyc.io) | - | 🚧 | - | - | - | - | 0% |
| [zkUSD](https://zkusd.money/#Features) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/zkUSDLabs)) | 🚧 | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://zkusd.gitbook.io/zkusd-documentation) | - | 0% |
| [Shade Cash](https://shade.cash) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/ShadeCash)) | 🚧 | - | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://shadecash.gitbook.io/shadecash) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [zk.money](https://zk.money) | ([Docs](https://docs.aztec.network/zk-money/userguide)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.aztec.network) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Yellow Submarine](https://ys.finance) | ([Docs](https://yellow-s.gitbook.io/docs/ys-basics/introduction)) | TBD | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [Sacred](https://sacred.finance) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Sacred-Finance)) | TBD | anon | - | - | 0% |
| [StealthPay](https://www.stealthpay.cash) | 🚩 **dead** ([GitHub](https://github.com/cryptoadong)) | TBD | anon | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [XATA](https://www.xata.fi) | - | 🚩 | anon | ([Docs](https://docs.xata.fi)) | - | 0% |
| [Offshift](https://www.offshift.io) | 🚩 **LOW** ([GitLab](https://open.offshift.io/offshiftXFT)) | live | ([anon](https://offshift.io/#team)) | - | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [Sahara](https://sahara.network) | - | 🚩 | ([Public](https://sahara.network/)) | - | 🚩 2022: [Vesting contract](https://sahara.network/resources/sahara-security-audit.pdf) | 0% |
| [Hurricane Protocol](https://hurricane.money) | 🚩 **no code** ([GitHub](https://github.com/Hurricane-Protocol)) | 🚩 | anon | 🚩 **marketing** [Docs](https://docs.hurricane.money) | - | 0% |
| 🚩 **sunset** [DeFiner](https://definer.org) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/DeFinerOrg)) | 🚩 | anon | [Docs](https://docs.definer.org) | 🚩 2020: [Savings audits](https://docs.definer.org/v/copy-of-definer.org/security/audits) | 0% |
| [Panther Protocol](https://www.pantherprotocol.io) | ([GitHub](https://github.com/pantherprotocol)) | [testnet](https://docs.pantherprotocol.io/docs/product-and-technological-components/product-versions/v1-testnet) | ([Public](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/)) | [Docs](https://docs.pantherprotocol.io/docs/start-here/panther-protocol-documentation) | 🚩 2021: [ZKP Vesting](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Vesting.pdf), [ZKP Token](https://www.pantherprotocol.io/resources/REP-Panther-ZKP-Token.pdf) | 75% |
**total**: 27 projects
**Details**:
- 17 🚧
- 25 red flags 🚩
- 6 sunsets
# Findings
## DeFi category
1. 38 projects
2. 25 🚩red flags
3. 17 🚧
4. 6 sunsets
**Before 🚧 criteria has been applied**
_high-risk category_
- 44.7% of the projects scored 0%
- 18.4% scored 25%
- 63.1% of the total projects - high-risk category (0-25%)
_low-risk category_
- 2.6% of the projects hit 100%
- 13.1% hit 75%
- 14.1% combined - low-risk category
_moderate risk-category_
- 21% - moderate risk-category
**GitHub**
- 27 projects (71%) have public GitHub
- 8 projects (29% among them) have dead or inactive GitHub (6 months +)
**security audits**
- 13 projects or 34.2% have third-party audits
- 8 projects have outdated audits (1 year+) - 61% (among those attested by a third party)
**docs**
- 21 projects (or 55%) have docs
- 5 projects (or 23%) among them = marketing docs
**After 🚧 criteria has been applied**
- 44.7% - 🚧
- 71% - 0%
- 13.1% - 50%
- 7.8% - 25%
- 5.2% - 75%
**Basic assessment, 🚩& 🚧 criterias applicability comparison**
| Observation | Basic | 🚩 | 🚧 |
| ------------- | ------------- | ------------- | ------------- |
| 100% | 5.2% | 2.6% | 2.6% |
| 75% | 23.6% | 13.1% | 5.2% |
| 50% | 31.5% | 21% | 13.1% |
| 25% | 23.6% | 18.4% | 7.8% |
| 0 | 15.7% | 44.7% | 71% |
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink